In these engines the water pump is not belt driven but has its own electric motor. It gains on fuel consumption, but it opens a new failure path: the pump or its electronics often simply stops with no warning. Measured in the official complaints, the typical mileage is 161,000 km (a tenth of the complaints already at 81,000, a tenth only above 257,000 km). So the common wisdom of "around 100,000 km" is early: most of the failures happen between 130,000 and 250,000 km.

Four aluminium bolts hold the housing of the variable valve timing (VANOS). On some six cylinder engines built between late 2009 and mid 2012 these bolts loosen over time, and can also break.

A rubber gasket seals the oil filter housing to the block. The gasket hardens over the years, and oil leaks from under the housing. The oil drips onto the drive belt and the alternator.

VANOS adjusts the position of the camshaft with the pressure of the engine oil, and a solenoid valve metres that pressure. The valve sits in the oil circuit, and a fine filter screen protects the spool inside it from larger particles. That screen clogs with carbon and deposits: less oil flows through, and VANOS then adjusts late or does not move at all. The symptoms are a rough idle, rough running, a lack of torque at low revs and higher fuel consumption, because the valve timing is off. A short metallic clacking can also come on a cold start and goes quiet after 10 to 20 seconds. The engine warning light comes on with a camshaft fault code, and depending on the severity the engine control unit switches to limp mode. The fault code narrows down the cause. P0010 and P0013 typically mean the solenoid valve itself, that is a circuit fault or reduced oil flow through the clogged screen. P0011 and P0014 point more to a mechanical cause: a stretched timing chain or a worn adjuster. P0012 and P0015 report late camshaft control, whose common cause is slow pressure build-up at the adjuster, so again the dirty valve. The valve itself is a small part, between 50 and 120 euro, and with a clean screen cleaning is often enough; replacing the whole adjuster, by contrast, is a four-figure job. The reported repairs ran between 80 and 1,200 euro, depending on whether cleaning is enough and how many valves are affected. The main cause of the screen clogging is a stretched oil change interval and carbon-laden oil.

The crankcase ventilation leads the gas that forms in the crankcase back to the intake and separates the oil out of it on the way. If the system clogs or the membrane tears, the pressure cannot get away: it finds a way out past the seals, or it pushes the oil through the piston rings. This is where the oil consumption comes from, and the oil that appears around the valve cover gasket. In the other direction a faulty breather takes unmetered air into the intake, and that is what makes the idle rough, the throttle response hesitant and the running coarse. Starting also gets harder, and in an extreme case the engine stalls at idle. Two characteristic signs help: weak or absent suction at the oil filler with the engine running, and noticeably rough running around 3,000 rpm. The hose at the rear of the valve cover can also let oil out. The sound insulation then soaks itself with oil, and oil gets everywhere in the engine bay. On the six-cylinder engines the breather is built into the valve cover, so the repair is replacing the cover or the whole oil separator together with the hoses, between 80 and 900 euro.

In the ZF six speed automatic (BMW codes GA6HP19Z / GA6HP26Z) the electrical connector of the valve body control leaves the gearbox housing through a plastic sleeve. That sleeve and its seals age, and they let oil through.

Valvetronic adjusts the lift of the intake valves, and an eccentric shaft does that work. Three parts can fail here, at very different prices, and their symptoms are nearly identical.